<- Back home

Essay

What if we all stopped paying for insurance?

November 2026healthcarePart of the healthcare series

If everyone stopped paying for health insurance, and you got seriously sick and could not afford treatment, you would simply die. You would not get the care, because you could not pay for it.

Insurance does not just process payments. It pools financial risk.

Suppose 1,000 families each pay $1,000 a month. That is $12 million a year.

This is a simplified hypothetical model, not actual insurance claims data. The point is the shape of the spending, not a real book of business.

Here is how that money might be spent

Hypothetical annual healthcare costs for 1,000 insured families
FamiliesAnnual costper familyTotal
950 with relatively modest healthcare needs$2,000$1,900,000
40 with serious medical needs$100,000$4,000,000
10 with catastrophic medical needs$500,000$5,000,000
1,000 total$10,900,000

Medical bills in this model come to $10.9 million. That leaves $1.1 million (9.2% of premiums) for insurance administration, reserves, and any profit.

Even if profit were zero, you would still need some administration. You would definitely need reserves. People do not wait until the next calendar year to get sick.

Where the $12 million goes
  • $1.9M — Modest care
  • $4M — Serious care
  • $5M — Catastrophic care
  • $1.1M — Insurance costs

Now imagine everyone stops paying

950 families

$10,000 ahead

They save $12,000 in premiums, spend $2,000 on healthcare, and come out ahead that year.

40 families

$100,000 bill

They save $12,000 in premiums, then face a serious medical bill many households cannot pay.

10 families

$500,000 bill

They save $12,000 in premiums, then face a catastrophic bill almost nobody can pay.

The 950 families with modest needs are financially better off that year. The other 50 are not. Many of them could not afford the treatment.

Insurance does not make those medical expenses disappear. It distributes them across a large population, so a bill that would ruin one household becomes a share of many.

And there is no guarantee that your family, with modest healthcare expenses this year, will not face a catastrophic illness next year. That is why we buy insurance.

What if seriously ill people simply could not pay?

That is the most consequential problem with eliminating insurance.

In the United States, emergency departments generally must provide emergency screening and stabilizing treatment regardless of ability to pay. That rule is EMTALA. It does not guarantee follow-up care, chemotherapy, specialist visits, medications, or long-term treatment.

If someone develops a serious illness and has neither insurance nor the money to pay, they can be denied necessary care that is not an emergency. Some of those people would die.

A hospital might provide charity care, negotiate a lower bill, or offer a payment plan. A government program might cover some patients. None of that is a universal substitute for insurance.

The real economic distinction

Healthcare financing does two different jobs.

01

Paying for predictable, routine expenses

Insurance is not the most efficient way to handle a $150 appointment or a $40 prescription. Running those through a claim mostly adds administration.

02

Pooling unpredictable, catastrophic expenses

Insurance is extremely valuable when one household faces a $500,000 medical event that almost nobody can afford.

Why are we using insurance to pay for routine, predictable healthcare instead of primarily protecting people from financial catastrophe?

The strongest argument for redesigning health insurance is not eliminating it. We need a highly competitive, low-cost healthcare system. I wrote about how to get there in We need abundance in healthcare. In that world, we would still benefit from catastrophic insurance.

We should make care cheaper through competition, price transparency, and less administrative overhead. Eliminating insurance does not eliminate the underlying medical costs, or the need to share catastrophic financial risk.

Catastrophic insurance would still need a workable answer for people who cannot afford even its premium or its deductible.